Pizza Shop Receives Prank Call and Prepares Large Order, then Another Business Owner Saves the Day

A pizza shop in Ohio faced a tough situation after a prankster ordered a large number of pizzas and didn’t pick them up. Thankfully, a local business owner stepped in to save the day.

prank call pizza order Ohio

In our day-to-day journey, we often come across trials that test our spirits and challenge our resolve. How should we react when deception knocks on our doors, or when our efforts seem wasted?

A pizza shop in Maumee, Ohio, found itself grappling with these questions after falling victim to a costly prank involving 16 large pizzas. The incident, which initially sparked dismay, transformed into a story of community support and grace.

PizzAroma, a local establishment known for catering to events, received an order for eight cheese and eight pepperoni pizzas to be picked up the next day. Rocky Keefer, the shop’s manager, did not suspect anything unusual and prepared for the order as usual.

Keefer shared that the woman who placed the order even called the following day to inquire when the pizzas would be ready, and he assured her they were being baked at that moment. The total cost of $112 was to be settled upon pickup.

However, the situation took a downturn when no one came to claim the order. The shop was left with no choice but to discard the now-stale pies. This resulted in not only financial loss but also a delay in service for other customers.

Further investigation by the shop revealed that the phone number used to place the order was traced back to an app designed for making prank calls with fake numbers.

Keefer revealed the disappointing outcome: “I can’t believe this happened because we took time out to make sure it was done. I just don’t understand why people can do that to somebody.”

The narrative shifted when Travis Truesdell, a local businessman and U.S. Army veteran, learned about the prank through social media. Moved by the pizzeria’s plight, he decided to cover the loss and further supported the business by buying additional pizzas to share with his employees.

Truesdell, owner of True Aerial Signs in Toledo, reflected on his actions, saying, “It just automatically resonated with me. I understand how hard it is sometimes to make ends meet. Doing the right thing is so easy, and it really makes a difference to other people.”

The incident sparked a policy change at PizzAroma. The staff decided that large orders would now require pre-payment, either over the phone or in person, to prevent future incidents.

Keefer expressed his hope that humanity was restored by Truesdell’s gesture, noting, “It’s nice that we have other small businesses looking out for us. Small businesses looking out for each other and have each other’s backs. It makes me proud.”

We are the hands and feet of God, and when we live out that truth, we can foster a healthy, loving community. Whenever we encounter someone in need—be it an individual or a business—it’s our call to step forward and help, sharing the love of Christ.

By supporting one another, especially small businesses that are vital to our local economies, we do more than just help them thrive; we weave stronger, compassionate connections that reflect the teachings of Christ.

Verse of the Day

“[Thanksgiving] I always thank my God for you because of his grace given you in Christ Jesus. For in him you have been enriched in every way—with all kinds of speech and with all knowledge—”

1 Corinthians 1:4-5